A Highlands and Islands MSP has urged the Scottish Government to take a calm and balanced look at both the potential benefits and the challenges of reintroducing lynx to Scotland, arguing that the issue deserves open discussion rather than polarised debate.
Ariane Burgess raised the issue in the Scottish Parliament, calling for farmers, crofters, wildlife experts, scientists, and local communities to be fully involved in shaping any future conversation about the species returning.
Her intervention followed concerns about the possible impact of lynx on livestock and rural livelihoods, with Ms Burgess stressing that those worries must be taken seriously alongside any environmental arguments.
She pointed to recent changes in Scotland’s farming and land management framework, which place a stronger emphasis on working with nature, and said the discussion around lynx should be considered within that wider context.
Ms Burgess said supporters believe lynx could help reduce deer numbers naturally, supporting woodland regeneration, healthier forests, and a more resilient natural environment.
She also suggested their return could bring wider benefits, including wildlife tourism and new rural jobs, particularly in areas already closely connected to Scotland’s landscapes and natural heritage.
Speaking during the debate, she said the issue should not be framed as change being imposed on farming communities who already face significant pressures.
“This isn’t about forcing change on farming communities.
“It’s about having an honest conversation that looks at the whole picture, the worries that farmers rightly have, but also the possible benefits.”
Ms Burgess said other European countries offer examples of how lynx and farming can coexist when proper safeguards and support are in place.
She explained that in those countries, farmers work alongside wildlife authorities to protect livestock, and compensation schemes are used where losses occur.
“Farmers’ concerns are real and important.
“That’s why we need proper plans to support them and answer their questions with facts.”
She said Scotland should learn from international experience rather than reopening old arguments without evidence.
Ms Burgess argued that decisions should be guided by shared understanding, with farmers, conservation groups, scientists, and government examining the evidence together.
“Good decisions come from good conversations.
“Let’s talk about this honestly and respectfully and find answers that work for both our farming communities and our wildlife.”
She stressed that any consideration of bringing lynx back would involve long term planning, detailed consultation, and meaningful support for those who manage the land.
The debate continues to divide opinion across rural Scotland, with strong views held on both sides.
Ms Burgess said that very division underlines why the issue should be approached carefully, openly, and without rhetoric.
