MSPs Back Calls to Scrap Council Tax as Pressure Grows for Fairer System

Scotland’s Council Tax system could be heading for its biggest overhaul in decades after MSPs backed a proposal calling for it to be scrapped and replaced with a fairer alternative.

The Scottish Parliament voted on Wednesday 18 November to support a Scottish Green motion requiring the Government to set out how Council Tax reform will form part of its planned reorganisation of local government.

The proposal received support from Green, SNP, Labour and Liberal Democrat MSPs, putting renewed pressure on First Minister John Swinney to address a system still based on property valuations from 1991.

Although the vote does not abolish Council Tax, it commits Parliament to a direction that could eventually change how households across Scotland contribute towards local services.

The current system divides properties into eight valuation bands, with bills calculated using assessments made more than 35 years ago.

Critics argue that this has created significant inequalities, with some households paying disproportionately more relative to the value of their homes.

Research from the Institute for Fiscal Studies has also raised concerns about the accuracy of existing Council Tax bands because of the age of the valuations being used.

The Scottish Government is proposing a wider reorganisation of local authorities, introducing regional and community levels of government, but its plans have not included a firm commitment to replacing Council Tax.

The Greens have made clear that their support for the wider reforms depends on changes to how councils are funded.

Scottish Greens co-leader Ross Greer said:

“I am delighted that MSPs have supported Green proposals to finally replace the broken and wildly unfair council tax.

“If most people were paying the wrong rate of income tax it would be a crisis, but governments of different stripes have sat on their hands for decades with the council tax, allowing it to become comically out of date.

“If the First Minister wants Green support for his plans to overhaul Scotland’s local councils, then replacement of the council tax is non-negotiable.

“There is no point in redrawing the map if we don’t fix the finances.

“Our schools, social care and other essential services depend on this.

“This vote was the first step in the right direction.

“Now the government must work with us to agree a fairer replacement for the council tax.

“The Scottish Greens have already put our plans forward, but we are ready to compromise with other parties in order to get this through Parliament.

“If no proposals come forward from the government though, Green MSPs cannot support their wider council reorganisation plans.

“Someone born when the SNP first promised to scrap the council tax is now almost 20 years old, that is long enough.

“We need to go further. Greens have already proven that fairer taxes on holiday homes and empty properties can raise hundreds of millions for local services whilst tackling local housing shortages.

“But our schools are desperately short of staff and our social care system is on its knees.

“Reorganising councils will achieve very little if these services are still left without a fair funding system.

“Tweaking an utterly broken system isn’t good enough.

“MSPs have given the government a mandate to go much further.

“They can now work with the Greens to finally scrap the council tax and deliver a fairer funding settlement for local councils.”

The parliamentary decision comes almost two decades after the SNP first committed to replacing Council Tax, a promise that has remained unresolved through successive Scottish Governments.

The motion calls for greater financial powers for councils and a more progressive replacement, although no final alternative or timetable for abolishing the existing tax has been agreed.

Any replacement would require further policy decisions and legislation, with implications for household bills and the funding available to local authorities.

For now, Council Tax remains in place, but the Scottish Government faces a renewed parliamentary demand to explain how and when it intends to change the system.

spot_imgspot_imgspot_imgspot_img
Joseph Kennedy
Joseph Kennedy
Joseph Kennedy is a senior writer and editor at The Highland Times. He covers politics, business, and community affairs across the Highlands and Islands. His reporting focuses on stories that matter to local people while placing them in a wider national and international context.
Latest news
spot_imgspot_imgspot_imgspot_img
Related news