Households across Scotland could face higher gas bills under plans to abolish standing charges, with the UK Labour Government acknowledging that some vulnerable consumers may lose out.
The warning follows written parliamentary answers confirming that while around 60% of households across Great Britain are expected to benefit from the changes, the remaining 40% are not expected to make a saving.
Under the proposals, the fixed daily standing charge on gas bills would disappear, with the costs currently recovered through that charge transferred to the price paid for each unit of gas.
This means households using relatively little gas could save money, while those with higher consumption could find themselves paying more.
The distinction is particularly important in Scotland, where colder temperatures and greater heating requirements can result in higher household energy consumption.
The SNP claims Scottish households use an average of 1,129 kWh more gas annually than households in England, potentially leaving a greater proportion of Scottish consumers exposed to increased costs.
Responding to parliamentary questions from SNP MP Graham Leadbitter, the UK Government acknowledged that some lower income and vulnerable households with unavoidable high gas usage could lose out.
Ministers also confirmed that the final impact would depend on individual consumption and how energy regulator Ofgem implements the changes.
The Government estimates that approximately 60% of households would save an average of £45 annually, although the remaining 40% are not expected to benefit financially.
The SNP argues that almost one million people in Scotland could be affected, although the Government has not confirmed how many Scottish households would face higher bills.
SNP Depute Leader Keith Brown has criticised the proposals, arguing that households in colder parts of Britain should not face additional costs because they require more energy to heat their homes.
He said:
“This is an outrage and Scottish voters deserve to know the truth.
“The UK Labour Government has just admitted they will inflict low-income and vulnerable households with even higher energy bills thanks to their standing charges policy.
“Make no mistake, those in colder climates like Scotland will pay more to subsidise lower costs in warmer climates down south, up to a million Scots are set to pay more.
“It’s welcome the Labour Government has admitted it so now they must put it right, but instead the Chancellor has ruled out any further support this winter.
“Energy rich Scots are braced for a harsh winter with bill payers here once again carrying the can to ensure that those in England pay less.
“There is a very simple injustice that Scots know all too well.
“Scotland produces the vast majority of oil and gas in the UK, and more than a third of renewable energy generation, yet under Westminster control we are forced to pay the highest energy bills in Europe.
“An injustice to which Westminster has no answer.
“Scottish voters were told the Labour Party would cut energy bills by £300.
“It is now on them to explain why bills will soon be more than £1000 higher than promised and why they have just asked those hit hardest in Scotland to pay even more to subsidise other parts of the UK.
“This is a national scandal that can only be addressed through a fresh start with independence, when we put Scotland’s energy in Scotland’s hands and put our vast resources to work for our people.”
The UK Government maintains that removing standing charges will give households greater control over their bills and reduce costs for the majority of gas customers.
Ministers have also promised targeted protection for vulnerable households with unavoidable high consumption, although the details have yet to be announced.
The reforms are intended to begin in 2027, or as soon as possible afterwards, leaving Ofgem to determine how the changes will be introduced and which households will ultimately pay more.


