Concerns are mounting across Scotland as the UK Government’s latest welfare proposals draw sharp criticism from disability campaigners and politicians alike.
A controversial plan by Labour to cut support for disabled people has been partly rolled back after a rebellion by some of the party’s own MPs.
But critics warn that the changes will still leave thousands worse off and create a two-tier system that punishes new claimants.
The backlash centres on changes to Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and health-related Universal Credit.
While those already receiving support are expected to remain under current rules, new applicants will face stricter eligibility checks under a system many say is already far too harsh.
Green MSP Maggie Chapman didn’t hold back in her response.
“This decision is good news but only for some people,” she said.
“It is testament to the hard work and determination of disabled people and activists who have been fighting to stop these brutal cuts.”
She said the partial u-turn may have helped calm tensions within Labour ranks, but fails to address the fundamental problem that thousands of disabled people will still be left without the help they need.
“Instead of creating a fair welfare system for all, Starmer has created a two-tier system,” Chapman said.
“New claimants will be subjected to a harsher regime and will not receive the benefits they need and deserve.”
She also accused the Prime Minister of abandoning Labour’s traditional values.
“It’s astonishing that a Labour government would ever contemplate such cruel and inhuman cuts,” she added.
“But after nearly a year of Starmer in Number 10, we’ve seen that he’s governing like a Tory in Labour clothing.”
The changes, which would apply across the UK, have sparked particular concern in Scotland.
Some Scottish Labour MPs, including Michael Shanks, are reported to have backed the plan, despite widespread opposition from disability rights groups.
Campaigners argue the move will deepen inequalities and further entrench hardship for people already facing daily struggles.
Maggie Chapman said the fight must go on.
“These rebels might have saved Starmer’s skin for now, but Greens will keep pushing back against these dangerous austerity measures,” she said.
“Scotland deserves a social security system built on dignity, not cruelty.”
For many watching closely, the message is simple.
Compassion should never be conditional.
