George Orwell imagined a society where Big Brother was always watching, and while modern Aberdeen is a very long way from the world of 1984, a new police surveillance trial raises important questions about how far technology should reach into everyday life.
Police Scotland is testing artificial intelligence software capable of searching hours of CCTV footage in minutes, with around 100 cameras involved in a three month trial across Aberdeen.
The technology, known as BriefCam, allows operators to search recorded footage for particular objects or descriptions, such as someone wearing a red jacket or a white car travelling through the city.
Rather than manually reviewing every minute of footage, officers can use the software to narrow thousands of possible matches to a much smaller number.
In one recent case, police say the technology helped trace an elderly woman after nine hours of CCTV footage were reviewed in approximately one hour.
More than 8,000 objects were narrowed down to just six possibilities, demonstrating the potential advantages when officers are searching for vulnerable missing people.
There is, however, an important distinction between what this technology does and what many people might imagine when they hear the words artificial intelligence and surveillance.
The system is designed to recognise and classify objects, including people, but Police Scotland says its facial recognition capability is disabled and cannot be accessed during the trial.
That means the software is not being used to identify people by matching their faces against a database.
Even so, the ability to search extensive CCTV networks at speed represents a significant development in how recorded images of the public can be examined.
Assistant Chief Constable Tim Mairs said:
“Police Scotland has a duty to the public and victims of crime to use new technology to enhance investigations and to keep people safe, but we know that people must have trust and confidence in the use of that technology.
“The BriefCam object recognition pilot comes after a robust governance period through a Rights Based Pathway which ensures processes are in place surrounding the introduction of technology in policing, focussing on human rights compliance, key ethical considerations and consultation with the public and partners.
“With a trial like this, we can test technologies that are available and explore how they can support us in responding to threat, risk and harm in our communities, and in a world that is increasingly familiar with Artificial Intelligence, it’s important that we keep up with the times and identify the tools that can support police officers to get the best possible outcomes.”
The trial builds on an existing CCTV partnership between Police Scotland and Aberdeen City Council, established in 2020.
The council has invested £1.8 million in developing its integrated camera network and operations centre.
Councillor Miranda Radley, Convener of Housing, Communities and Public Protection, said:
“Aberdeen City Council has invested £1.8 million in developing an integrated CCTV network and Operations Control Centre, bringing together technology and resources to support public safety across the city.
“Working closely with Police Scotland, this investment has strengthened the ability to monitor incidents, support investigations and respond to emerging situations.
“This pilot builds on that investment, exploring how video analytics can help officers review CCTV footage and identify relevant information more quickly.
“Ultimately, this is about making better use of the existing infrastructure, supporting Police Scotland in preventing and detecting crime and helping keep Aberdeen’s communities safe.”
Police Scotland says the project has undergone scrutiny covering human rights, ethics and public consultation, with its effectiveness to be assessed before any decision about wider deployment.
The Scottish Police Authority will also consider the findings when the trial concludes.
The prospect of tracing a missing person more quickly is a compelling argument for the technology, particularly when every hour can matter.
But there are equally legitimate questions about how searches are authorised, who can access the results and what safeguards would remain in place if the system were introduced throughout Scotland.
The cameras themselves are not new, but the ability to analyse what they record is changing considerably.
And that is perhaps the most important question raised by Aberdeen’s experiment, not simply whether the technology works, but how much surveillance a society is prepared to accept in return for greater security.


