Britain could gain almost seven times more from returning to the European Union than from the agreement reached in Brussels on Friday, according to new economic research that has intensified the political argument over Brexit.
The Productivity Institute has estimated that full EU membership could eventually increase annual UK economic output by around £112 billion compared with the country’s existing trading arrangements.
That contrasts with the £17 billion annual improvement projected by Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s Government following its latest negotiations with European leaders.
The difference has prompted the SNP to challenge whether Britain’s current approach goes far enough to recover the economic opportunities lost through Brexit.
Published on 20 November, the Productivity Institute’s research examined several possible relationships with Europe, including full membership, closer trading agreements and a customs union.
Its modelling suggests that returning to the EU could increase UK economic output by approximately 3.67% in the long term, once potential improvements in productivity and business investment are considered.
The researchers also estimated gains of £54 billion through an arrangement resembling those of Switzerland or the European Economic Area, and £38 billion through a customs union.
However, these are forecasts based on economic assumptions rather than guaranteed returns, and the researchers acknowledge uncertainty surrounding future investment and productivity.
The Government’s £17 billion estimate also relates to projected economic gains by 2040, meaning the two figures are not directly comparable forecasts over identical timescales.
Nevertheless, the findings highlight how much economic value researchers believe could potentially be recovered through a closer relationship with Europe.
The SNP argues that the difference strengthens the case for Scotland returning to the EU through independence.
Its Westminster trade spokesperson, Chris Law MP, said:
“Any steps to ease the damage caused by Brexit are welcome, but this is nothing even close to rejoining the EU, this is Andy Burnham’s new Brexit deal.
“His own estimates suggest this measure will bring £17bn to the UK economy per year at best, that’s the same amount of money the UK borrowed last month alone, it’s nothing in the grand scheme of things, and dwarfed by what we stand to gain by rejoining.
“Andy Burnham must at long last make up his mind and stop taking the people of Scotland for mugs, he must set out if he wants to rejoin the EU, and if so, how.
“Scotland never voted to leave the EU, and we should never have been forced to, the best way to guarantee a fully fledged return to the EU is with independence for Scotland.”
The SNP has suggested that Scotland’s population share of the projected economic benefits could amount to approximately £1.36 billion annually under the new agreement, compared with £9 billion through full EU membership.
Those figures are simple population based estimates, however, and do not account for differences in Scotland’s industries, trading relationships or economic structure.
There is also an important distinction between increased economic output and government revenue, with neither forecast representing money that would automatically become available for public spending.
Friday’s agreement includes measures intended to reduce barriers affecting food and agricultural exports, reconnect emissions trading systems and expand opportunities for young people to work and study in Europe.
These changes could offer practical advantages to Scottish businesses, particularly those affected by additional export requirements since Brexit.
The UK Government maintains that closer cooperation can deliver economic benefits while retaining control over Britain’s wider trading arrangements.
Full EU membership would involve additional commitments, including freedom of movement, contributions to the European budget and participation in shared rules.
For Scotland, independence followed by EU membership would also require negotiations and the agreement of existing member states.
The research does not settle those political choices, but it places substantial figures against the different economic possibilities.
And almost a decade after the Brexit referendum, the question facing Britain is no longer simply what leaving Europe has cost, but how much of that economic damage it is prepared to reverse.


