Scotland must have a greater say in future agreements between Britain and the European Union, according to the Scottish Government, which has welcomed progress at Friday’s summit while warning that the economic damage caused by Brexit remains unresolved.
Minister for Europe and External Affairs Stephen Gethins has called on Prime Minister Andy Burnham to involve the Scottish Government more closely in negotiations affecting devolved responsibilities.
The intervention follows the UK and EU summit in Brussels on 20 November, where agreements were reached on reducing barriers to food and agricultural trade, expanding opportunities for young people and linking carbon emissions trading systems.
The arrangements could benefit Scottish businesses, particularly food and drink producers who have faced additional paperwork and trading restrictions since Britain left the European Union.
A new Youth Experience Scheme would also create opportunities for young people to live, work, study and travel between Britain and participating European countries.
However, the agreements still require further legal procedures before implementation, with outstanding questions over university tuition fees also needing to be resolved.
Mr Gethins believes the summit represents progress but argues that individual agreements cannot fully replace the economic and social advantages of EU membership.
He said:
“Scotland is a European nation, and we support any immediate steps towards a reset of the partnership with our neighbours in Europe, particularly where they strengthen our security and help people and businesses struggling with everyday costs.
“Today’s agreement is a start, but the fact remains that the current deal will only unpick a small part of the immense damage that Brexit continues to inflict on our economy and our living standards.
“The Scottish Government has long called for the restoration of travel, work and study rights, as well as the removal of unnecessary red tape holding back businesses such as those in our valued food and drink sector.
“We will consider the full implications of this deal.
“If the UK Government wants to act in the interests of all people and businesses across the UK, it must drop its red lines on the Single Market, Customs Union and freedom of movement.
“It’s regrettable that did not happen ahead of these negotiations.
“The Scottish Government needs to have a clearer say in shaping any future deals with the EU, but for now we expect to work with the UK Government on today’s agreement where measures touch on areas of devolved responsibility.
“That expectation will extend to the European Partnership Bill, which will be a significant test for the Prime Minister if he wants to prove he is serious about engaging with us.
“lt must not become another case of decisions being made for Scotland, rather than with Scotland.
“But ultimately, Scotland’s interests will only be served by rejoining the European Union, not by half-measures.
“And it is now clearer than ever that the way for us to do that is as an independent member state.”
The European Partnership Bill will provide an important test of how the agreements are implemented, particularly where new arrangements involve responsibilities held by the Scottish Parliament.
The UK Government argues that closer cooperation with Europe can improve economic opportunities while maintaining Britain’s position outside the EU, single market and customs union.
Scotland’s ministers take a different view, maintaining that full membership would provide greater economic opportunities and political influence.
Any return to the EU as an independent Scotland would require a formal membership application and negotiations with existing member states.
For now, the summit offers the prospect of fewer trading barriers and greater cooperation, while leaving the wider constitutional and political questions surrounding Scotland’s relationship with Europe unresolved.


